Compare/ReplyGuy
Radar vs ReplyGuy
ReplyGuy's job is to mention your product in other people's threads, at volume, across the web. On Reddit, their own FAQ says they use purchased accounts emailed to you. Radar will not do that. Every Radar reply is your account, your paste, your disclosure if the product is named. If you want a machine mentioning you while you sleep, they are built for it. If that sentence makes you uncomfortable, Radar is the tool that agrees with you.
Radar is for
Founders who will only speak as themselves, under their own username.
ReplyGuy is for
Teams optimizing for mention volume and willing to use ReplyGuy's Reddit account model.
I still paste every reply myself
I built Radar because Hunt plus a pasted reply on Reddit is how I actually reach people. I run it on ColorHer (photo restoration) and SHIP FM (startup radio). Radar never posts. I copy the draft, open the thread, and paste under my own name. Help-only when pitching would be spam. Founder disclosure when the product belongs in the reply.
I'm selling this because I can see it helping me get seen — and paid. OPs answer. People check the FM. A first customer showed up. I am not going to invent a round number for you.
The tools on this page that auto-post or buy accounts are a different job. I flinch at that, so Radar stops at the draft. I still paste by hand. That is the product.
The loop is public: @robsannazzaro on X.
What they have that we don't
Auto-replies
Paid plans include auto-replies and monthly reply quotas.
Purchased Reddit accounts
Stated on replyguy.com FAQ. Twitter stays manual.
Multi-project keywords
They sell the 1–2 hours/day back. Volume is the pitch.
What Radar holds onto
Your name on the comment
No second identity. No silent account.
Mechanical honesty
Founder disclosure when you pitch. Help-only when you should not.
Whose account
ReplyGuy. Reddit replies can go out from accounts they provide. That is a feature they document.
Radar. If it is not your account, Radar has nothing to do. The product ends at the clipboard.
Choose ReplyGuy if volume-from-other-accounts is acceptable. Choose Radar if it is not.
Price
Analyst $39/mo (no auto-replies) through Agency $499/mo. Pro $49/mo includes auto-replies. From replyguy.com, Sep 2026.
€19/month flat after 10 free copied replies. No reply quotas at any price — quotas sell the volume that gets founder accounts banned.
Their product changes. We read public pages on replyguy.com/ in September 2026 and did not sign up to every dashboard. If something here is stale, that is on us — email and we will fix it.
More comparisons